It can happen here. And it Has.

November 6, 2024 7 Comments

Trump’s victory is a grim day for the United States and for democracies around the world. You have every right to be appalled, saddened, shocked, and frightened. Soon, however, you should dust yourself off, square your shoulders, and take a deep breath. Americans who care about democracy have work to do. ” Tom Nichols in Nov 6, 2024 The Atlantic

My night was disrupted by constant despondent messages from my European friends and readers – not that I could sleep anyhow. I found myself embracing conspiracy theories rather than acknowledging the real horror of this election outcome: the majority of American voters are happy to act on racist, misogynistic, patriarchal and christian nationalistic impulses. The spectacle of cruelty and power, of ignorant belief in empty promises and a desire for traditional hierarchies restored, attracted millions of voters, White women and men predominantly among them. Embracing the fact that they are empowering a convicted felon and his coterie of oligarchs and supplicants. Equality, as enshrined in the Constitution, but an empty term.

Who would not rather believe that voting machines were manipulated, by oligarchic shenanigans or foreign powers, that bomb threats and voter suppression disrupted the process, that votes were systematically not counted, than to admit in what company of landsmen we exist?

The grief I feel today is compounded by the fact that German history is so closely associated with my life as German-born, as a Jew, as a scientist, who sees the writing on the wall, whether it will be show trials for opponents of a malignant narcissist, withholding of disaster aid to blue states, willful ignorance of scientific data ranging from vaccination denial health care decisions (welcome back, polio and diphtheria, measles and pandemics,) to climate change in what short window of time we still have. The damage will be irrevocable.

Millions around the world will pay the price for this nation’s election, starting with the Palestinian and Ukrainian peoples who will have fought in vain against genocidal aggression. The grief is compounded by knowing that so many of my younger friends or children’s generation worked so hard for a better future, throwing themselves into canvassing and other organizing work, because they realized that their own future is so much more endangered than that of my generation that soon will be gone.

I know that autocrats’ goals are to instill fear in us, and exhaustion, isolation, disorientation. George Monbiot wrote in The Guardian before the election:

Never underestimate the vengeful nihilism at the heart of this movement. The glitter-eyed fanatics behind Project 2025 and other such programmes will smash whatever is most precious to you, partly at the behest of commercial interests – but also to enjoy watching the pain it inflicts. They will crush beauty, joy, community and hope precisely because other people value them.

Well, they will try. There will be a time to resist that, to move and organize and understand that those of us who are privileged as white middle class people are called on supporting the multitudes of more vulnerable fellows. But today I grieve. I withdraw. I have nothing else in me. I had gotten my hopes up, unable to fathom the depth of racism that drives this country and the lust for hate, and fell all the more. Allow yourself to grieve, too, if you share these fears. Then we’ll figure out what comes next. Together.

November 11, 2024

friderikeheuer@gmail.com

7 Comments

  1. Reply

    Martha Ullman West

    November 6, 2024

    Well, very well said. Let’s cope with our sorrow and our rage in whatever manner suits us temperamentally, an then get on with it.

  2. Reply

    Ken Hochfeld

    November 6, 2024

    Tears. For how long, only time will tell. As for the addage “Good triumphs evil”, well, gone for now. How can we not mourn? I will mourn with all my dear friends knowing there are some of us out there. Certainly not the majority of our fellow countrymen, for now. Maybe eyes will open and hearts will prevail. Just not now.

  3. Reply

    Philipl

    November 6, 2024

    People are already starting to organize. Anybody who needs to rest should do so without guilt. Your contributions so far are immense, so you have earned your self care activity.

    Thank you for sharing your thoughts!

  4. Reply

    Ruth Ross

    November 6, 2024

    I am bereft and heart broken. Thank you for your words; they help inform my crazy emotional thoughts.

  5. Reply

    Sara Lee Silberman

    November 6, 2024

    You have expressed so well what your privileged white middle class friends and family think and feel at this deeply alarming moment (i.e., start of four years…).
    For what it’s worth, I will report a reference point I heard on NPR an hour ago, namely, that our last three one-term presidents all presided over terms that, whether it was their fault or not, were periods of inflation. “It’s the economy, stupid!” was the point that particular commentator stressed as a major causal factor for the Trump majority. That point does not, of course, obviate our deep, well-founded concern about what’s next….

  6. Reply

    Kimberly Marlowe Hartnett

    November 6, 2024

    Brilliant. You captured the history and the heartbreak.

  7. Reply

    Michel Saran

    November 7, 2024

    Liebe Friderike, Du hast es hervorragend ausgedruekt. Ich habe den Krieg und die Nazizeit als Kind erlebt, einen Totalangriff auf meine Gebutsstadt und bis zum 23zigsten Lebensjahr in der DDR gelebt. Was Totalitarismus bedeutet weiss ich sehr gut. Die vergangenen Systeme konnten niedergerungen werden, die jetzigen sind Grossmaechte! Wird es eine Solidaritaet der Demokraten geben? Liebe Grüsse Michel

LEAVE A COMMENT

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

RELATED POST