Browsing Category

Art

My child could paint this!

· The Marla Olmstead Story ·

IMG_4156 copy 2

I remember childhood summers spent at the North Sea in Holland, mixing buckets of sand and water in just the right proportion to drip the mud through my fist, forming what looked like little pine trees. It was a visceral pleasure to grab and release that viscous mix onto the beach. When I look at a Jackson Pollock painting I often wish I could return to that state, using my hands with thick paint instead of mud.

Unknown

Another favorite activity was raking patterns into the wet sand close to the waves, with expansive sweeps and twirls, running, freeing your body from the constrained movements urged on girls in polite company. I can almost feel my arm swinging again when looking at a Phillip Guston painting, a kinetic experience.

schwabsky_guston_FULL_img

I wonder if the attraction of abstract art which allows not to think about “meaning,” for some of us, then, is the ability to re-live an experiential state. Art critic Harold Rosenberg claimed that painting for Pollock and other abstract expressionists was an event, the meeting with paint an encounter. Perhaps their paintings creates echoes of action rather than cognition in our perceptions, an emotional memory of earlier, freer times. In addition, some  neuroscientists suggest that our brains have mirror neurons, which would show activation mirroring the movements of the painters when creating the work. These elusive neurons are a hotly debated topic across perception research; I, for one, still need convincing.

http://www.wired.com/2013/12/a-calm-look-at-the-most-hyped-concept-in-neuroscience-mirror-neurons/

And yet the very idea that a child could paint an abstract masterwork, or that those famous artists had reverted to a more child-like mode, has people question the validity of the art. The best example of this was an affair some ten years ago around a 4 year old child prodigy, Marla Olmstead. Taking the art world by storm with her abstract paintings and making big money, 60 Minutes eventually questioned her abilities and declared she had grown-up help, parents who enabled fraud. A subsequent documentary by Amir Bar Lev installed hidden cameras to catch her in the act, and discussed  the media frenzy around it all, itself becoming some sort of exploitation. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=j46V9wclBaw (The entire film is also available on youtube).
People were obsessed with finding out “the truth” – to what end? Would a child’s ability to create an abstract master work, devoid of cynicism, painted in child-like naiveté, really void the accomplishment of adults’ paintings? Is the very assumption that that might be possible an acceptable reason that so many people dismiss abstractionism?  I’ll continue to explore this tomorrow.

Abstract Art is dead. Long live Abstract Art!

· Paintings of Lee Musgrave ·

Egg-Red copy

In 1940 the New Republic published an article written by Wyndham Lewis, a painter himself, with the title The End of Abstract Arthttps://newrepublic.com/article/80125/the-end-abstract-art  This witty, sometimes pompous, obituary was clearly premature. If you look at the catalogues of modern art museums in this country and around the world 76 years later, you find the art form dominates the field. Countless journal articles explore its theoretical underpinnings, trying to predict a trajectory.

Closer to home, you find serious artists engaged in its application. Lucinda Parker, Whitney Nye, Terrel James and Gwen Davidson are among them. (Note, all women!) I chose to showcase Lee Musgrave. I like his work and know him as a fellow photographer who walks the same landscapes as I do. I thought it would be interesting to compare photographs of some subjects with his painterly extractions around the same matter. My current take on it is that painting beats photograph every single time. A photograph is of course the pinnacle of representation – the capture of something at a given moment of time. Depending on how much of a thing you photograph it can be more or less  abstract, but really it is of a thing, a documentation. Lee’s abstract painting, on the other hand, draws out some essence, value added by the application of craft, the creation of imagined juxtapositions. Judge for yourself. (Note, I took all these photos long before I even met Lee, planning to use them as building blocks for montages.)

LeeMusgrave_Rendevous#2,45x84

IMG_4094

 

 

 

LeeMusgrave_Happenstance#9-Impulvise,30x40

 

DSC_0223

 

LeeMusgrave_FromHereToThere,60x60

DSC_0107

 

 

LeeMusgrave_InTheNow#2,40x30

DSC_0121

And here is the match for the lead montage – egg above meet chick below! At least that’s what I see in this painting with the little chicken feet, superimposing reference once again.Schorschi'sWall,60x60

Non-referential, huh?

· Confusion reigns - but that's probably me ·

DSC_0243 copy 5

Written by the editors of the Encyclopedia Brittanica: “Abstract artalso called nonobjective art or nonrepresentational art, painting, sculpture, or graphic art in which the portrayal of things from the visible world plays no part. All art consists largely of elements that can be called abstract—elements of form, colour, line, tone, and texture. Prior to the 20th century these abstract elements were employed by artists to describe, illustrate, or reproduce the world of nature and of human civilization—and exposition dominated over expressive function…. Abstract art has puzzled and indeed confused many people, but for those who have accepted its nonreferential language there is no doubt as to its value and achievements.”

Let’s look at an art critic’s alternate universe (and just so you know how my mind works I chose an art review based on a name of an abstract painter – how can one not explore the art of someone called Cy Twombly?) And I quote:

“It is a cliche that abstract art is distant from real life, impenetrable and remote. Twombly is an abstract painter who tells stories of love, longing and loss. His art is always tangy with experience – it drips life.” Jones refers here to a painting about Hera and Leander, dedicated to Christopher Marlowe, and interprets splotches of color quite convincingly as blood, misty seas, evocations of watery graves (true for all three referenced persons in one way or another.) Note that the references depend on your knowledge of myth and/or history, but references they are, red allegedly representing the bloody fate of Marlowe. Twombly’s paintings, which I have only explored on the web, are of astonishing beauty, storytelling or not. He died some years ago.Cy-Twombly-Hero-and-Leand-007

The lead montage, by the way, is part of my series On Transience that was exhibited last year at the Oregon Jewish Museum. The subject matter concerned the nature of Jewish emigration, and the transient psychological state that comes with displacement in general.

Where does all this leave the quest for understanding abstract art? Yesterday we learned the canon has been challenged; today we find that accepted definitions of the nonrepresentational nature of abstract art is confronted with claims of a representational narrative structure inherent to it after all. Did someone mention confusion?

Will I ever understand Abstract Art?

· We will find out. Or not. ·

DSC_0020 copy

I know very little – really next to nothing – about abstract art. Sometimes I think that interferes with my appreciation of abstract paintings, sometimes the opposite seems to be true. Same for creating abstract photographic montages. So I figured I take this week to learn something about it and share what I found. Be prepared for a lot of direct quotes – and a lot of digression when other things popped up in my reading.

Here is a quote from Charles Jencks, critic, landscape designer, polemicist and one of the most interesting writers explaining modernism: …”For the founders of the Museum of Modern Art, the canonic story of Modern art led from Neo-Impressionism through Fauvism to Cubism, the Bauhaus and Modern Architecture (capitalized, as the gospel ought to be). This canonic trajectory led directly to Abstract Art, and it determined the arrangement of works in the galleries of MoMA right into the 1980s. This canon also justified a view of history as aiming toward abstraction as its goal, and, at the same time, validated the major bloodline of Modern artists from Picasso through Jackson Pollock…” (MoMa has now changed its exhibition patterns away from historical periods towards subject driven collections – underlining in the quote by me.)

The attached article http://www.harvarddesignmagazine.org/issues/14/canons-in-crossfire is really about architecture and cycles of creativity – I came across it accidentally because it quoted a book I am interested in  – Creating Minds – An Anatomy of Creativity Seen Through the Lives of Freud, Einstein, Picasso, Stravinsky, Eliot, Graham and Ghandi – by Howard Gardner. (Hey, in English! Paperback!) But it got me wondering about what someone who clearly thinks aiming towards abstraction can NOT be the goal, would strive for instead. Turns out Jencks believes the desire to know and relate to the universe, to understand the cosmos, is one of the strongest drives of sentient beings. His landscape art, abstract and yet content driven, is attempting to do just that. Look at his website http://www.charlesjencks.com/#! under projects and you understand what he’s after.  Do I now know more about abstract art? Hm. Not really. Stay tuned.

charles-jencks-cells-of-life-at-jupiter-artland-designboom-02

 

 charles-jencks-cells-of-life-at-jupiter-artland-designboom-03

Worpswede

· A German Artist Colony ·

Turquoise Sky copy

My grandmother Dora grew up as one of 11 children on a small holding in Lower Saxony; her parents worked the lands for large estate owners, and had a small plot of their own to feed the ever growing family, a hard life. The soil is sandy there, not very fertile, with large swaths of heather, juniper and crooked birch woods; you can look at paintings of that landscape if you visit the museums in what remains of one of the preeminent artist colonies in Germany, Worpswede. http://www.worpswede-museen.de/en/kolonie-kuenstler/colony-and-artists.html

These days the most famous visual artist from that village is Paula Becker Modersohn, who was heads and shoulders ahead of her time, a precursor to German expressionism. She was a rebel, lover of Rainer Maria Rilke and, it is rumored, his wife Clara, wife to Otto Modersohn, tragically dead of a postpartum embolism at age 31. She sold perhaps one painting in her lifetime, surrounded by a bunch of more or less talented landscape painters who ruled the day. There are more than ten biographies about her, none of which I could find in English translation and she now has her very own museum in Bremen.

DSC_0119 copy 2

Worpswede is a big tourist attraction, lovingly restored, with museums, historical homes, pretty pine forests. A recent German novel, Concert without Poet, that depicts the poet Rainer Maria Rilke’s bad boy days in Worpswede became a national bestseller and serves as yet another draw for the curious. It undercuts the narrative of the happy big family of artists in prewar times, and dishes out juicy gossip. Another untranslated novel, The Man who fell through the Century, describes the involvement of several colony artists with Naziism, dealing another blow to the Worpswede hagiography. In any event, the village is off the beaten path from the cities most Americans plan to visit, but a true locus of German art history.

The lead montage is based on a sculpture by Bernhard Hötger, the other montage on an excerpt of a Becker Modersohn painting of a little village girl. The panting below is a sketch by one of my favorite male artist of that Worpsweder group, Hans am Ende.
410804980

 

 

Les Corbeaux

· Bonus: Trompe L'Oeil at the Louvre ·

Crow(n) of Thorns copy

If memory can be trusted – and I wouldn’t, necessarily – the background of this montage was based on a photograph taken two years ago at the Louvre. Something about that luscious chair appealed. The focus, however, was supposed to be the crow – a bird species I hold special feelings for. When my children were young I convinced them (probably one of the last times I convinced them of anything) that I could communicate with crows, and you could see me flapping about the backyard, wildly cawing, to the consternation of the bird population and probably the amusement of the rest of the neighborhood.

Crows are not just quite intelligent birds, they are culturally adaptive, superb tool makers and sport an incredible multitude of voices and expressions. For a short introduction there is the TED talk below, for longer perusal there is an interesting book, In the Company of Crows and Ravens, by John M. Marzluff.

https://www.ted.com/talks/joshua_klein_on_the_intelligence_of_crows?language=en

DSC_0084 copy 7

If you are lucky enough to travel to Paris in the next months and if the Louvre is on your list of things to see, you will be surprised. The I.M. Pei pyramid in the courtyard, so controversial at its inception and so beloved now, is playing hide and seek. Muralist JR, commissioned by the museum, is casting a trompe l’oeil spell over the structure. The article below explains in more detail (and is surprisingly catty when discussing work of another graffiti artist, Banksy.) https://www.theguardian.com/artanddesign/jonathanjonesblog/2016/may/26/louvre-pyramid-trompe-l-oeil-jr-im-pei-paris-museum  I, by the way, when first visiting, was startled by all these people in front of the pyramid holding up their arms until I inquired: if you photograph them from a specific angle, it looks as if they are touching the top of the pyramid.  Another bit of useless knowledge crowding my brain……

5045

IMG_2415

IMG_2409

What ever happened to NEVER AGAIN?

· Visit the Oregon Jewish Museum and Center for Holocaust Education ·

HeuerFriderike_Dresdner Braut
On December 17, 2012, the Simon Wiesental Center issued a travel advisory for Copenhagen and Denmark, following a warning by the Israeli Ambassador to Denmark, advising Israelis not to wear kippot, jewelry with religious symbols, or to speak Hebrew on the streets of the Danish capital. The advisory followed reports of physical attacks on Jews in Copenhagen. This in a country which throughout Nazi occupation during WWII treated their fellow Jewish citizens as equals. And in striking acts of courage and humanity, Danes saved all 7,500 Jews from certain death at the hands of the Nazis by spiriting them out to neutral Sweden. Norway had issued a travel warning already in 2006.

Last year the Central Council of Jews in Germany advised against wearing the traditional Jewish head covering in what they called “problematic areas,” later named as Muslim neighborhoods in Berlin and other large cities. http://www.spiegel.de/international/germany/german-jews-advised-against-wearing-kippah-a-1020890.html  This year, the head of the Jewish Community in Marseille followed suit, sending out a warning after an attack on a teacher (although France’s head Rabbi Haim Korsia urged Jews not to follow that advice. http://www.ibtimes.co.uk/france-marseille-jews-urged-not-wear-skull-caps-public-1537608 .) Note, by the way, that many of us recoil at the idea of seeing people forced to give up their traditional religious clothing for fear of persecution, but have little to say about the state bans of wearing Hijab in many countries.

The lead montage is based on a photo taken at the Jewish Museum in Berlin (Albertine Mendelsohn-Bartholdy, by August Kaselewsky.) The museum’s paintings and photographs of middle class German Jews (see below, Max Slevogt, Familienbild Plesch 1928) bring home once again the striking fact how completely integrated and indistinguishable Jews were from the rest of the population  –  little did it do to prevent catastrophe.

IMG_1787

Shout out to a Jewish Museum of our own: The Oregon Jewish Museum and Center for Holocaust Education http://www.ojmche.org  – do yourself a favor and grab the last days of their current exhibit of photographs of photojournalist Ruth Gruber who was a twentieth-century pioneer. The photographs in this exhibition span more than fifty years, from her groundbreaking reportage of the Soviet Arctic in the 1930s and iconic images of Jewish refugees from the ship Exodus 1947, to her later photographs of Ethiopian Jews in the midst of civil war in the 1980s.

4 RG_gruber_portrait fur camera

Off the Beaten Path

· Museo de Arte de Ponce ·

Flaming July 2012 copy
This week I decided to dig for some of my favorite montages in the archives as long as they were connected to interesting locations and/or facts.  Some have been exhibited, some are just personal favorites. Several were precursors to a series called “Zwischenräume” – The Spaces in Between. This series was partially inspired by a stanza from Georg Kreisler’s “Song of Reality,” which he wrote in exile in the US having fled Nazi occupied Europe, describing the tension between truth and fiction, science and fantasy – something that holds for much of current political discourse but also, alas, for science reports.

Today’s montage was based on a famous painting by Sir Frederic Leighton, Flaming June. I expect her to get up any moment and dance – have to ask Martha in which ballet. I found the painting in a small but terrific museum in the middle of nowhere in Puerto Rico – the Museo del Arte de Ponce. http://www.museoarteponce.org. It is architecturally interesting, holds a fine and substantial collection of European art, particularly pre-Raphaelite pieces, and, most importantly, gives equal attention to modern Caribbean artists. The Leighton piece attracts visitors in all its orange glory, but there is much to see for more discerning patrons as well, including modern sculpture outside. My day there, in all its perfection, found a worthwhile ending with a number of daiquiris at dinner…

Unknown

Puerto Rico is in trouble. Puerto Rico’s population has been falling for nearly a decade, and the pace of decline has accelerated in recent years. Although a slowdown in the island’s natural population increase has contributed, a more important factor recently has been a sharp surge in the out-migration of its citizens. Nearly one-third of those born in Puerto Rico now live on the U.S. mainland and it is mostly the younger people who leave. Part of the reason is the huge economic crisis faced by the island. Here are some of the details: https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/wonk/wp/2015/06/29/things-in-puerto-rico-are-getting-really-bad-what-you-need-to-know/.  Clearly, an increase in tourism would benefit the dominion, and one wonders why people aren’t enjoying the weather, the tropical beaches, the charming capital with its old forts and plazas in larger numbers. You don’t need a passport, or foreign currency, everyone speaks English and the island has a diverse biosphere, from arid regions to rainforests to caribbean beaches. Below is a photograph I took at the old Fort in San Juan – the figures reminded me of Aglaea (Splendor), Euphrosyne (Mirth) and Thalia (Good Cheer) aka the three Graces.

Three Graces

 

 

 

From Smirk to Smile

· Cultural aspects of smiling ·

IMG_8999 copy 3

Can we explain why people in some countries smile and in others don’t? Why women smile more often than men? Scientists have certainly tried to do just that – and the data are a mess, if you look at them closely. Some hypotheses are interesting. You could assess countries for a factor called uncertainty avoidance  –  cultures with unstable political and economic systems, where the future is seen as unpredictable and uncontrollable are low on this scale and perceive smiling as a stupid sign of overconfidence. If, on the other hand, you rate countries for corruptness, you find that smiling is perceived to be correlated with dishonesty. Masculinity of a culture or hierarchically structured cultures might have an influence on smiling, as does the fact that some cultures value happiness less than others. Details can be found here: http://www.theatlantic.com/science/archive/2016/05/culture-and-smiling/483827/ Read it and frown.

The busker in the montage above came from Poland – unclear if the frozen face is part of his national or his caked-on make-up. You find a lot of them in touristy areas close to the Eastern borders, hoping for the support of generous tourists appreciating their act. Below are his American counterparts, maybe it’s the make-up after all….

IMG_6230

 DSC_2019 copy

I learned quite a bit from the attached piece on the smile in portraiture throughout the centuries. The images alone are worthwhile a short perusal. (Carravagio’s Triumphant Eros included.)

http://publicdomainreview.org/2013/09/18/the-serious-and-the-smirk-the-smile-in-portraiture/

9784401585_3bbfe42d11_o

Note, my musings don’t end on a smiley face, maybe the hierarchical structure of my German upbringing is counteracting gendered tendencies……

Curtain Call

· Open and closed ·

 

IMG_5228

They’ve delivered quite a performance, those curtains. In real life and in art. Time to call them back for a bit of applause. They divide rooms, shelter from the cold, keep out the light, let in the light, soften the light. They assure privacy, they hide and they reveal. Iron curtains divide nations, velvet curtains enhance the stage, netted curtains keep mosquitos at bay.   They’ve been used since antiquity and adapted to each historical time, from simple woven linen and wool in 17th century European homes to the pomp around the Rococo period where velvet and silk ruled, particularly around canopy beds (or so tells me the encyclopedia brittanica http://www.britannica.com/topic/curtain-interior-decoration.)

If you search for painted curtains in an effort to find good art, you get a zillion ads for painted shower curtains, van Gogh’s Starry Night seemingly one of the favorites. But I lucked out by finding a wonderful collection of classical paintings here http://www.apollo-magazine.com/drawing-the-curtain/. Moreover I learned a lot from the art historian’s evaluation of the role of curtains in painting. What stuck with me most is the fact that the painted curtain is a divide between the content of the painting and the viewer, being part of both worlds, covering and uncovering, inviting exploration while interposing. For today’s classical painting I chose William Larkin (early 1580s – 1619) who painted the court of James I in England, and was know as The Curtainmaster. Almost every one of his portraits was framed in curtains, of varying colors and materials, and although the paintings seem flat overall, the folds and fluidity of the drapery is impressive.

Diana_Cecil_1614_William_Larkin
440px-Philip_Herbert_4th_Earl_of_Pembroke_c_1615

 

And let’s not forget all those who have to wash, starch and iron those curtains….

IMG_5349 c