The Recurrence of Everything.

How shall I put it? If I had been a member of the award committee, this year’s Booker prize would have not been unanimously granted to M. John Harrison’s The End of Everything. True despite my appetite and respect for science fiction, a genre that deserved to be acknowledged after all these years.

The short (198 p.) novel reminded me of one of those Jell-O puddings served at children’s birthdays of yore, coming out of an intricate mold. Beautifully detailed, glistening (Harrison’s way with language is exquisite), flashy in attention-getting colors, a feast for the eyes. Little of substance once you cut into it, wobbling under your knife, crumbling into shape-shifting bits, providing no sustenance.

“Don’t you get the point?,” I will be scolded, “That’s all that’s left after we destroyed meaning.” Huh?

Let’s try again, long version. (And as per usual, spoiler alerts). The novel is set during an unspecified future, in a still recognizable England, cut off from the rest of the world. Over some decades, an infestation of aliens, the iGhetti, have littered the land with oozing garbage, jell-O-like slime that might have triggered my association, come to think of it. They took over London, currently still under bombardment by unspecified human defense forces, centering on the symbols of capitalism, some finance towers of the past. They build shiny, reflective edifices reminiscent of commercial chains all over the country.

They or something in their wake wash ashore as small biological entities, soon to grow into something physically mimicking adult human beings, language, skills, emotional repertory and all. These artifacts mix with the remaining population, people who rush from one conspiracy theory to the next, trying to explain the nature of what is happening. Explanations of mentioned catastrophes are withheld. Meaning nowhere to be found.

Well, we have plenty of hints, come to think of it. The German phrase for heavy hinting is “Ein Wink mit dem Zaunpfahl,” pointing with a fence post. A fence, in our case, the length of the Chinese wall. iPhones that ghettoized us, Internet that disrupts human interaction, AI which made knowledge acquisition painless, the shortcuts rendering our knowledge unreliable, our capacity to discern compromised, if not vanished altogether. Climate change that destroys the world, nostalgia for a misremembered past, (particularly the heroes of WW II) that opens up to easy manipulation. Brexit leading to an isolation expressed in the vanishing of the rest of the continent(s). A glut of signifiers, without appropriate receptacles able to make sense of them. Which one or ones caused the alienation? Sad to say, a point in every direction amounts to no point at all.

***

The narrative centers around an aging artist in the throes of quickly advancing dementia, with all that entails, from memory lapses to violent episodes. Marnie resembles her literary predecessor in the 1961 Winston Graham novel of the same name (later adapted, if changed, by Alfred Hitchcock in the mid 1960s.) She is not a reliable narrator, leads a nomadic existence, enacts a lot of criminal energy, all the while torpedoing the possible positive relationships she could have. All in all a subversive and transgressive character, who is allowed, in the contemporary novel, to escape towards an unspecified ending, potentially finding home. She has barely a tooth left in her mouth – maybe she’ll survive on Jell-O….

As an artist, she is supposedly concerned with the “big questions,” painting signs that ask HOW CAN YOU MISPLACE A CONTINENT and holding them up in public, proposing the words “less as a subject for debate than some reified metaphysical manifestations.” (p.153) Her profession also gives the author a chance to throw in the occasional art-related quip that establishes a quick recognition among the cognoscenti, making you feel like belonging to a desirable club. (Done, admittedly, with knock-out word-smithing.) There are descriptions of condiment containers shaped after de Chirico women, and “Mondrian-adjacent” bicycling shirts reappropriated as blankets. “I’m writing for you, unusually educated reader,” you almost hear the lines whispering!

Piet Mondrian Landscape with meandering River (1906)

Piet Mondrian, by the way, would have relished Harrison’s truly authentic and exquisite writing about landscape, I presume. The master of atmospherics of the Dutch polders would see himself mirrored by a devotee of the British heath. It’s the only time reality has a sturdy foundation in this book. It is also a time where humor is allowed to creep in (p.88): who does not relish a bijou nature preserve?

Piet Mondrian Dune Landscape (1911)

***

Marnie criss-crosses this landscape after leaving unspeakable violence in her wake – our first encounter with her sees her desanguinating a 12 year- old child with a knife and after thorough preparation, punishment for a youthful prank. Later she shoots people, including her nephew Phillip who was an important part of her life, kills him and ingests some of his ashes before she turns to something akin to cannibalism. Phillip brought an alien artifact into her life who later becomes her companion and driver, now attacked and devoured after she sees “it” form a relationships with another alien.

As I have often mentioned here, I cannot stand gratuitous violence as an attention-getting tool, ever increasing in volume and cruelty in both contemporary literature and film. I don’t even care, if these events are meant to be part of Marnie’s demented fantasy or to be taken as real. The mad artist is, after all, matched by the mad scientist, Hampson, in this novel, whose violence extends to the disemboweling of his parents and scores of the living “artifacts” brought to him by beach combers and sold as treasure. He uses them as antennas or receptacles in a desperate attempt to establish communications with the invaders.

I first misread his name as Hamsun, with immediate visions of asocial characters that populated this Norwegians author’s novels and the horrifying history of his collaboration with the Nazis, another invading force that changed the world at its time. Likely an association too far, my brain on overdrive.

All Hampson wants is knowledge, some facts to ground his understanding about the world they have inherited, some reassurance that organizing principles still exist, to fend off fears of random evolution. “GIVE ME MEANING!”

I don’t care if he is driven into psychotic actions by a world that provides no sense, or Marnie is driven by psychotic impulses of a mind that lost its senses – the reader is helplessly forced into revulsion, and then immediately roped into narrative scenes of the most pedestrian nature. It is as if a moral compass is just a wildly rotating needle with no determination point. Wobbly like jell-O.

That effect is exacerbated by the absence of any materialist grounding, landscape and historical architecture excepted. How do people get their food, find gasoline or electricity to drive the cars, provide the motor boats that help the desperate to flee for an unknown horizon? How does life go on seemingly in oblivion, with bands making music in the market place, pubs offering food and housing, families frolicking on beaches that occasional are strewn with showers of ash? Have humans surrendered to their fate, and just keep trudging on, embracing banality instead of revolt? Are some still able to refuse to surrender and if so, how?

Marnie’s nephew reunites, before his unfortunate demise, with a former flame named Alice. Like Alice in Wonderland, we meet her at a tea party (a children’s birthday,) like Alice she has survived numerous characters of dubious tethering to reality. She decides to leave on a boat for something better, anything at all, with no guarantee, of course, that the fate that awaits is an improvement over the current unmoored existence. Remember the end of Tim Burton’s movie Alice in Wonderland inspired by the original Lewis Carroll tales? Alice departs on a boat seeking “real” life instead of surrendering to an unreal world.

***

We learn that not just our protagonists but large swaths of the novel’s population occasionally suffer intrusive thoughts, or flashbacks of recurring memories, instantiated with slight variations, but inescapably repetitive. These fugue-resembling episodes are called “going through a bad patch.”

I wonder if Harrison’s novel before us could be thought of as one of those. He already wrote a series with the same themes and preoccupations, Viriconium, starting in 1971, over half a century ago, this reader barely in her twenties then and hooked. Read this effusive review of another one of his novels, and tell me if it applies to The End of Everything or The Sunken Land Begins to Rise Again. (Hint, the review was written in 2020, so the latter.)

How often can you describe the fact that our epistemic climate pushes us towards the easy short cuts and the flashy ideas? How often can you point us to the fact that we should be applying ourselves to the hardship of acquiring knowledge, the right ways of doing it, before we end up with shallow knowledge bases and the inability to apply serious analysis beyond short form summaries?

Where are we alerted that we also have a responsibility to choose what type of knowledge we should be seeking? What is important to know and how are we obliged, as communities, to make choices about the beliefs we try to establish, grounded in facts? How can we learn to embrace our responsibility to know, to establish meaning? Repeat warnings that we dumbed ourselves down and that we are like Goethe’s Sorcerer’s Apprentice inviting forces that we will be unable to control, don’t suffice. Teach me something, both halves of the story: the current lack of epistemic virtue during knowledge acquisition and the goals we should have about the substance we should get to know, to avoid surrender to potentially arriving evil.

And do so clearly enough for this common reader (who will, of course, never sit on the Booker Committee…)

Of course, another science fiction writer (and uncommon reader) had her own take on things: Ursula LeGuin reviewed Harrison’s collection You Should come with me now in 2017, a year before her death.

“Fiction that abandons cause and effect makes a point about the nature of reality at its own expense. Narrative inconsequentiality offers the imagination limitless freedom, but the paradoxical result of such freedom is predictability. When you see that in this story nothing is going to happen which, by the ancient rules and rites of storytelling, “should” happen, interest wanes. Relationships are without effect, and therefore without affect.

If surrealism is super-realism, and if reality is indeed as vacant as this, no wonder we make up lies about it. Merely realistic or merely fantastic fiction asks us not only to consent to suspend disbelief but to believe that actions have reactions, acts have consequences and moral responsibility exists. Storytelling of this kind seems to be a human survival tactic.

Surrealism is the most cerebral and most cynical of genres, declaring and exhibiting the falsity of reason, the meaninglessness of meaning; it flaunts its courage in breaking the compact, the collusion, on which fiction depends. But such brave defiance runs the fatal risk of boring the reader. “

What she said.

Floating into Fall.

Weaving Time: NUNO – Textiles of Tradition and Transformation at Portland Japanese Garden.

If you are interested in textile design and live on the West Coast, you are currently in luck. The Los Angeles County…